Do Your Mutual Funds Hold the Same Stocks? How to Check Overlap
Two mutual funds with different names can own many of the same companies. Here is what holdings overlap means, how it is worked out, and how to check it for free on Jivani Markets.
· 4 min read
पढ़ें हिन्दी मेंMany people own three or four mutual funds and feel well spread out. The names on the statements are different, the mutual fund houses are different, and each SIP goes out on its own date. But under the names, two mutual funds can be buying many of the same companies. That shared part is called holdings overlap.
This article explains what overlap measures, how the number is worked out, and how to check it for your own mutual funds on Jivani Markets.
What Overlap Means
You own units of a mutual fund, not the shares inside it. The mutual fund house uses the money to buy stocks and bonds, and publishes the list every month. That list is the mutual fund's portfolio.
Holdings overlap is how much of two portfolios sits in the same names. On Jivani Markets it is counted the same way everywhere: for each company both mutual funds hold, take the smaller of the two weights, then add those up.
A 60% overlap means more than half of the money in the two mutual funds sits in the same places. A 10% overlap means they have little in common.
A Worked Example
The numbers below are made up, to show the maths. They are not any real mutual fund.
| Company | Mutual Fund A | Mutual Fund B | Counted |
|---|---|---|---|
| Company P | 9% | 6% | 6% |
| Company Q | 7% | 8% | 7% |
| Company R | 5% | not held | 0% |
| Company S | not held | 4% | 0% |
| Overlap | 13% |
Company P is in both, so the smaller weight, 6%, counts. Company Q is in both, so 7% counts. Companies R and S are each held by only one of the two, so they add nothing. Across these four companies the overlap is 13%. A real portfolio has many more holdings, and the same rule runs over all of them.
The smaller weight is used because that is the part of each portfolio that is truly the same. If one mutual fund puts 9% in a company and the other puts 6%, only 6% of each is the same bet.
Why the Number Is Worth Knowing
Overlap is not good or bad on its own. It is a fact about what you already own. A few things it helps you see:
- How spread out you are. Two mutual funds with a high overlap move more like one mutual fund than like two.
- Where the shared money sits. The list of shared companies shows which names you are exposed to through more than one mutual fund.
- Same category, same pool. Two mutual funds in the same SEBI category, such as two large-cap mutual funds, pick from the same pool of companies, so a high overlap between them is common.
What you do with the number is your decision. The site shows the overlap; it does not tell you to keep, switch or sell any mutual fund.
How to Check It on Jivani Markets
Holdings X-Ray
Open Holdings X-Ray and add the mutual funds you hold. You can search by name, browse a SEBI category and add a scheme, or screen and add the matches.
- One mutual fund: see every stock and bond inside it, from the latest monthly portfolio the mutual fund house published.
- Two or three mutual funds: the page blends them and shows the Overlap between them. Holdings that sit in more than one of your picks are called out.
- Weights: two or more mutual funds start at equal weights. Switch to Percent or Parts to match how your money is actually split. With Parts, 1 : 2 : 1 becomes 25% / 50% / 25%.
One mutual fund's x-ray and the overlap of up to three mutual funds are free. Four or more mutual funds together, month-on-month changes and split suggestions need the Investor plan or Max.
Compare Mutual Funds
Compare Mutual Funds puts mutual funds side by side. Its Holdings Overlap section shows two numbers for each pair:
- Holdings in Common: the same smaller-weight overlap as above.
- Price Moves: how closely the two NAVs moved together, measured on daily returns. 1.00 means they moved as one; 0 means they had nothing to do with each other.
With two mutual funds it shows How Much They Share. With three or more it shows Every Pair at Once, a grid with the overlap of each pair on one side and the price correlation on the other. Signed out or on the free plan you can compare three mutual funds; the Investor plan compares six.
From a Stock Page
You can also start from a company. On a stock page, the line that says how many mutual funds hold the stock opens a reverse x-ray: which mutual funds, SEBI categories and mutual fund houses hold that stock.
Things to Keep in Mind
- The portfolio is last month's. Mutual fund houses publish holdings once a month, so the overlap is as of that list, and the page shows the date.
- Some mutual funds disclose no portfolio the site can compare. Compare then still shows price moves.
- Overlap looks at holdings, not returns. Two mutual funds can have a low overlap and still move together, which is why Compare shows price moves too.
Overlap is one of the simplest checks you can run on what you already own, and it takes a minute.
Try It
Holdings X-Ray
The stocks and bonds inside a mutual fund or your whole portfolio.